Don’t believe the hype about prepaid cards. But don’t believe the doomsayers, either
We live in a world of incessant hyperbole. The latest version of the iPhone? Best invention ever. The current members of Congress? The most corrupt and feckless in history. And let’s face it, advertising and promotion is based largely on inflated claims such as these, and that includes the efforts companies use to pump up interest in prepaid debit cards. To hear card issuers describe them, prepaid cards are the most convenient, reliable and safe financial products ever conceived. But that is, of course, hyperbole. The truth involves a great deal more nuance. There are, in fact, some real benefits, especially for people who don’t have or can’t get traditional credit cards. There are also significant red flags with prepaid cards, ones that any consumer should be aware of. So all hyperbole aside, let’s take a look at a few of the good, bad and ugly qualities of prepaid cards.
The Upside
- Easy, easy, easy. One of the main reasons people carry around credit and debit cards in their wallets is because it’s so darn easy to use them. Accepted virtually everywhere – at restaurants, shopping malls and even parking meters – plastic is simply more handy than cash. Prepaid debit cards provide that same convenience, including being able to get cash when you have to have it from ATMs all around the world.
- Under your management. With features like online account management and email alerts when you’re close to exhausting your available funds, prepaid cards give you easy control over how you spend your money. They’re also simple to replenish via direct deposit or by using a credit or debit card.
- Web ready. Try logging on to Amazon and buying a book or DVD with cash. Uh, it doesn’t work. Online retailing is exclusively the domain of those who have plastic. Thankfully for those who don’t have a credit card, prepaid cards can be your portal to online purchases.
- Safety first. There’s no need to walk around with large wads of cash when you have a prepaid debit card. Importantly, and unlike cash, losing your card doesn’t mean the money is gone forever, especially if you report the loss immediately.
- A snap to get. Unlike credit cards, there’s no credit check if you apply for a prepaid card. Just sign up, fund the card and go.
The Downside
Just like any other means of payment, prepaid debit cards possess a number of disadvantages. Here are a few.
- Fees, fees, fees. Although they vary from card to card, fees are inevitable. Whether it’s a monthly account maintenance charge or getting dinged to withdraw money from an ATM or even to add cash to your card, there’s no way around at least some fees. And if you use your card a lot and its fees are onerous, that amount can pile up quick. Which is why being a savvy, conscientious comparison shopper is vital.
- Not earning credit. One of the main reasons consumers gravitate towards prepaid cards is because they can’t get a credit card. But relying on a prepaid card will do nothing to help you build the sort of credit history you need to eventually get one. Since the money to fund a prepaid card is, by definition, given upfront, there are no repayments and hence nothing to report to the credit bureaus that track that behavior. If you want to build credit, look into a secured credit card.
- Not yet ubiquitous. Even though prepaid cards are gaining in popularity, they are not yet universally accepted at all stores. It’s always best to check with a merchant before you make a shopping trip.


