Posted July 14, 2015 by Shane Tripcony in News

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s Proposed Prepaid Card Regulatory Changes Inspires Industry Response

Text to show Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) vs. NBPCA Over Proposed Prepaid Regulations
Text to show Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) vs. NBPCA Over Proposed Prepaid Regulations

When the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) was created in 2010, nobody expected it to play nice with the financial services industry. Authorized as part of the Dodd-Frank legislation, the CFPB was tasked with protecting consumers from predatory lending and other Wall Street abuses that spawned the Great Recession. From the very start, the financial services industry and its allies in Congress resisted the formation of the CFPB, and even successfully torpedoed the choice of now-Senator Elizabeth Warren to lead the agency. Now, a new battle is about to commence: the CFPB is gunning for prepaid regulatory changes.


In the handful of years since the CFPB began its oversight of the financial services industry, it has scored a number of consumer-friendly victories. Largely unheralded by the media, the CFPB has managed to do everything from force credit card issuers to be more transparent about the interest charges related to balance transfers to handling hundreds of thousands of consumer complaints. Red Boxer (CFPB) Squares Off with Blue Boxer (NBPCA)More recently, the CFPB has placed the prepaid debit card industry in its crosshairs and, not coincidentally, triggered concern and angst from the Network Branded Prepaid Card Association (NBPCA), an industry trade group.

The proposals by the CFPB and the responses from the NBPCA are a classic illustration of the inherent adversarial relationship between regulators charged with protecting the interest of consumers and industry eager to help its businesses remain as profitable as possible. For example:

  • The CFPB would like to apply the more rigorous regulations that apply to credit cards to certain prepaid products, especially those that allow customers to overdraft or overdraw their accounts. This application of what is known as the Federal Reserve’s Regulation Z to certain prepaid cards is opposed by the NBPCA, which says it’s the sort of restrictive regulation that limits options for consumers and may even result in customers opting for riskier products.
  • The CFPB has proposed expanding the definition of what a prepaid debit card is, the result of which would be more an expansion of the number of products subject to government regulations. The NBPCA, by contrast, wants to limit the definition to only primary account transactions, which take the place of a debit card tied to a checking account.
  • There is some overlap in what the industry and the government want to see in the realm of disclosure about fees. Both the CFPB want more disclosure, though the industry group wants a single template for disclosure while the government has proposed a number of them.
  • Even the speed with which the government’s rules would go into effect is a matter of debate. The CFPB has said nine months is plenty of time for prepaid card issuers to adapt to the new rules while the NBPCA believes it will take between 18 and 24 months.

The final determination about the rules that will govern prepaid cards in the future is still being hashed out. Scales of Justice: CFPB vs NBPCAAnd while it would be easy to decry this sort of back-and-forth as yet another instance of Washington paralysis, there’s a case to be made that this process is working just as it should. No industry wants to bear the increased time and money it requires to comply with new rules and regulations, especially when it comes at the cost of profits. But this adversarial relationship between the prepaid industry and the CFPB could and should result in a range of protections that ensure consumers aren’t victimized. At the same time, the input of industry should ensure that whatever new regulations get enacted don’t drive the efficiency and consumer value out of prepaid debit cards.

If both happen, then consumers will have more confidence in prepaid cards generally, which is a win for both the CFPB and the NBPCA.


Shane Tripcony